Vayeshev: Joseph's Labors in Exile


Vayeshev: Joseph's Labors in Exile


Perhaps our greatest question in life is: do our actions have true significance? The performance of mitzvot is metaphysically meaningful, but what about our day-to-day activities? Ultimately, how much of our lives and pursuits truly matter?

39 Types of Melachah

The Mishnah [Shabbat 7:2] enumerates 39 categories of melachah, activities that are not permitted on the Sabbath, such as planting, cooking, and building. Is there something special about the number 39? The Talmud in Shabbat 49b presents two possibilities. The first opinion is that 39 types of work were performed when constructing the Mishkan (Tabernacle) in the desert. And the second opinion is that the word melachah (in its various forms) appears 39 times in the Torah.

In fact, the word melachah appears 65 times, but the Sages were only counting verses that somehow relate to Shabbat or the Tabernacle. Thus we find that the Talmud was not sure which verses should be included in this count of 39. One of the verses in question, from the reading of VaYeshev, speaks of Joseph's labor for his Egyptian master, Potiphar: "And he came to the house to do his work" [Gen. 39:11].

Why should this verse be counted? Surely it has no connection to the Sabbath!

What Belongs to the Realm of Shabbat?

We must first understand these two views presented in the Talmud, connecting the 39 categories of activity either to the building of the Mishkan or to the word melachah in the Torah.

The Sabbath day of rest is in total contrast to the days of activity and work. The Sabbath belongs to the final goal of the universe, a time when all activity is finished. Work, by definition, indicates a state of incompleteness. Shabbat, on the other hand, is "mei'ein olam haba," a taste of the future world, perfected and complete.

We live in an unfinished world of preparations and laboring, of development and progression. The Tabernacle was a center of holiness within a spatial framework, subject to the limitations of our incomplete world. The Divine command to construct a Tabernacle required that all the various categories of human activity be utilized in building it. The Jewish people needed to overcome and master the temporal obstacles that obstruct elevated life; then they could attain their ultimate objectives, holiness in living and closeness to God.

The second opinion quoted in the Talmud comes from a loftier perspective. The distinction between kodesh and chol, between the holy and the profane, only exists within our incomplete and divided reality. But when all of the forces and actions in the world are gathered together towards one elevated center, when all of life is directed to fulfill its true purpose, then the distinction between holy and profane disappears, and all aspects of life are bound together in one elevated union of "kodesh kodashim," the Holy of Holies.

When we view the world through this higher prospective, adding the dimension of "kodesh kodashim," then all activities become connected to the Sabbath ideal. All of life is related to the sublime aim of absolute rest, without toil and preparations, only enlightened joy and eternal value. The view that sees in every mention of melachah in the Torah as relating to Shabbat is not satisfied with ascribing meaning and significance only to the kodesh, only to those activities utilized to build the Mishkan. This is a inclusive vision that encompasses the holy and the profane, the natural and technological. Bound together, all activities are sanctified with the holiness of the Sabbath day and the future Sabbath realm. Not only is the holy center raised up, but also the branches, all of the forms of activity and melachah as recorded in the Torah.

In short, these two opinions deliberate our original question. The Talmudic discussion of what may be counted as the source for the melachot is, in fact, our question of how much of life truly 'counts'. Are only holy activities truly meaningful? Or is there eternal significance even in other aspects of life?

Labor for Alien Goals

According to the second, more inclusive view, the Sabbath encompasses all activities of the Jewish people, both past and future, personal and national. However, the Jewish people in their long history have expended much time and energy in dispersed directions. Many Jews used their best talents in serving alien agendas. This is the essence of the Talmud's doubt regarding Joseph's labors in Egypt. Can individual activities performed in foreign lands for foreign goals still be counted as part of the accumulated service of the Jewish people over the millennia? Do they have eternal value?

On the one hand, it cannot be that the labors of a Jew will not carry the residual imprint of the Jewish nation. Even if it was 'planted' on foreign soil, that which is suitable can be added, after removing the dregs, to the treasury of elevated Sabbath rest that Israel will bequest to itself and all of humanity.

On the other hand, labor that was performed under foreign subjugation and enslavement is perhaps so removed from the spirit of the Jewish people that it cannot be added to the national treasure of Israel.

Joseph's Labors under Potiphar

Joseph, the Midrash states, represents the entire Jewish people [Tanchuma VaYigash 10]. Even when laboring in Egypt, even as a slave under Potiphar and in the jail, his actions carried the mark of blessing and Divine success. "His master realized that God was with him, and that God granted him success in all that he did" [39:3]. "God blessed the Egyptian because of Joseph" [39:5].

Nonetheless, we should not forget Potiphar's position: chief executioner under Pharaoh. The activities that Joseph performed under Potiphar's direction were certainly alien to the spirit of Israel. Could the inner blessing of Joseph's labors under such conditions be added to the treasury of activities connected to the perfected realm of Shabbat? This was the unresolved doubt of the Talmudic scholars, whether to include the verse describing Joseph's labors in a strange land.

[adapted from Ein Ayah vol. III pp. 7-9]

Not Everyone is Included in the Four Species

From The Writings of Rav Binyamin Ze'ev Kahane in honor of Sukkot Organs of power at home joining the side of our enemy requires us t...